Chris McCully

Fishing Diary

Next Entry

And the winner (Sea-trout) is....

Monday, 11 December 2017 at 15:36

Teal Blue Silver These are the last statistics I'll provide on flies that according to the diary records have been my most successful since the 1970s. You'll find stats and patterns for river trout, stillwater trout and grayling below. That brought me to sea-trout. Extraordinarily hard-fought category, this. How, really, can you compare between flies for Irish white trout (in lough, river, estuary), Scottish sea-trout (in loch, river, estuary), and Danish and other saltwater sea-trout? For saltwater, White Minkie and Pattegrisen (Pink Pig) did well, as did various Sunk Lures. Muddlers did well everywhere (generally black/yellow or natural/white), as did the Medicine. Of traditional patterns, Donegal Blue and Silver Daddy were outstanding, as were the Kingsmill (which I rarely fish these days) and the Claret Bumble. Yet there was one clear winner (drum roll): the Teal, Blue and Silver (sizes 8-12).

And the winner (Grayling) is....

Monday, 11 December 2017 at 09:42

Sawyer's Bug The statistics for grayling (please see below for stats on running-water and stillwater trout) are partial. Over the past fifty years I've probably caught as many grayling long-trotting as I have with the fly-rods. Nevertheless I had a go through the diaries, which show that I caught my first grayling in 1971. In reverse order, John Storey and PTN did well; KlinkhÄmers and Goldheads; dry Iron Blue and Grey Duster; Dove Bug; leaded patterns such as Shrimp and Hoglouse. One thing that did surprise me was the success of the dry Terry's Terror (sizes 16-18): clearly I fish this as an alternative to Red and Orange Tags. Of the traditional wet-flies, Orange Partridge and Snipe and Purple scored quite well. Yet one pattern stood head-and-shoulders above the others. And the winner is.... Sawyer's Grayling Bug. (Shown in the image is a Grayling Bug tied by Frank Sawyer's wife -a fly that, judged from its now mangled - and repaired - appearance, has already done sterling service on the Avon and elsewhere.)

And the winner (Stillwater trout) is....

Sunday, 10 December 2017 at 21:27

Cove PTN After ranking flies for flowing water (see below) I then ranked my records for stillwater trout. I didn't include everything: trout under 10 inches were discounted. It was also difficult classifying the patterns: the category 'midge pupae' for example included underwater pupae, hatching pupae (i.e. flies fished in the surface film) and dry midges. I didn't generally list for particular colours of natural pupa or sedge. Midge representations of various kinds were far and away the most successful patterns. The dry Daddy, the G&H Sedge and various Hoppers (fished dry) also scored well. The Pitsford Pea was the most highly-scoring lure, followed by the Viva. Of the traditional wets, Dabblers (especially the peerless Pearly Dabbler) did well, as did the Zulu, (Silver) Invicta and the Black Pennell. Yet by a fairly narrow margin, the outright winner was...the Cove PTN, a stylisation of any dark-bodied midge pupa.

And the winner (Flowing Water trout) is....

Sunday, 10 December 2017 at 16:52

Leaded Shrimp Because the weather's been dreadful I finally got round to working out totals for the most successful flies in the fly-boxes. The totals were extracted from angling diary records going back to 1968 - nearly fifty years. Provisionally I sorted the records into categories - Flowing Water (browns and rainbows), Stillwater (browns and rainbows), Sea trout, and Grayling. So far I've looked at totals just for Flowing Water. The result surprised me: strongly represented were general patterns like the Funneldun (the most successful dry pattern) and the Black Gnat; for nymph-suggesting patterns the PTN and the GRHE scored well; the Waterhen Bloa was the most successful traditional wet-fly. Honourable mentions ought to go to the KlinkhÄmer, the John Storey and the Grey Duster. As the totals mounted, for a while it was neck-and-neck between the star of the show and another weighted pattern, the Leaded Caddis, but ultimately there was only one winner: the Leaded Shrimp.

Fly-tying weather

Sunday, 10 December 2017 at 11:17


More fly-tying weather

Sunday, 10 December 2017 at 10:10

Silver birch

The Grafham flies: Big Red

Wednesday, 6 December 2017 at 09:08

Big Red Fishing's been at a standstill for five weeks - a combination of work and domestic circumstances which has left me chained to the desk or in a worrying relationship with the A1, a road I'm getting to know rather too well. Still, I've done a bit of fly-tying and last weekend was reviewing the patterns that seem to have worked well at Grafham over the past season. (I rarely fish Grafham for trout in the winter, though the lake is open till the end of January and there are those who swear that the winter months offer some of the best of Grafham's bank fishing.) Though I caught fish on buzzers, Daddies, Snakes, Hare's Ears and even the odd Blob I usually used more or less representative patterns and of them, have here selected a dry pattern, a pupa, a floating fry and the Pitsford Pea, which last is a sort of mini-lure.

The Big Red (size 12) is a great dry-fly and one I used (and will use) gladly throughout the summer and early autumn. It's slightly more vulnerable then the other patterns listed here - the parachute hackle tends to get mangled in trout teeth - so I tie and carry plenty.

Previous Entries
November 2018
October 2018
September 2018
August 2018
July 2018
June 2018
May 2018
April 2018
March 2018
February 2018
January 2018
December 2017
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
          1 2
3 4 5 7 8 9
11 12 13 14 15 16
19 20 22 23
24 25 27 28 29 30
Powered by WebGuild Solo

No Contact Details

This website ©2005-2018 Chris McCully